Editorial Policies / Editorial Policy
Policy 02 of 15
Editorial Policy NFSU
Who holds decision-making authority, the journal's turnaround commitments, when papers are desk-rejected, and how manuscripts are transferred.
[02]
Decision-making authority
The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority over all editorial decisions. Section / associate editors manage individual manuscripts and make recommendations, but do not issue the binding decision.
Turnaround targets
14 days
Submission → Publication
The fast-track pipeline targets publication in 14 days. Every stage is tracked in the author dashboard.
Day 0–1
Submission & Triage
Manuscript submitted through the ORCID-authenticated portal. Completeness, formatting and scope checked. iThenticate + AI-content screening runs automatically.
Day 2–3
Editor Assignment & Reviewer Invitations
Subject editor assigned. Two reviewers invited in parallel, matched via ORCID + Publons history.
Day 4–9
Peer Review
Structured reviewer reports on originality, methodology, clarity, significance and ethics. Identities never exposed.
Day 10–11
Editorial Decision & Author Response
Accept · Minor Revision · Reject. For minor revisions, authors respond within 4 days.
Day 12–13
Production: Copyedit, Typeset & Proofs
Copyediting, JATS XML + PDF + HTML typesetting, figure checks. Author proofs within 24 hours.
Day 14
Publication, DOI & Indexing
Published online; Crossref DOI activated. Metadata pushed to indexers within 24 hours.
As formal outer-limit commitments, the journal guarantees:
| Commitment | Outer limit |
|---|---|
| First decision (from submission) | < 30 days |
| Publication (from acceptance) | < 90 days |
Please note
Targets are commitments, not guarantees; complex or contested manuscripts may take longer.
Desk rejection criteria
A manuscript may be rejected by the editor without external review where any of the following applies:
- Out of scope for the journal.
- Below the quality or novelty threshold, or seriously incomplete.
- Duplicate or concurrent submission to another journal.
- Ethical violations, undisclosed conflicts, or failure to meet submission requirements.
- Similarity above the accepted threshold — see the Plagiarism Policy.
Transfer policy
Where a manuscript is sound but better suited to a sister title, the editor may offer a transfer. Transfers are made only with author consent; reviews already completed may travel with the manuscript to speed the process.
Questions
Editorial queries, including transfer offers, should be directed to the editorial office at editor@nfsu.org.