Skip to main content
Peer-Reviewed Open Access · CC BY-NC 4.0

Editorial Policies / Standards, Indexing & Q1/Q2 Readiness

Transparency · Indexing · Ranking Readiness

Standards, Indexing & Q1/Q2 Readiness NFSU

One auditable view: every policy mapped to the international standard it meets, plus readiness against the databases that matter — Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed/PMC, DOAJ, Crossref and Publons — and an honest guide to what quartile ranking actually requires.

Publisher: (National Forensic Sciences University) National Forensic Sciences University Effective: July 2026 Version: v1

How Q1 / Q2 really works

Quartiles are not set by policy. They come from citation metrics — Scopus CiteScore quartiles and Web of Science Journal Citation Reports (JIF) quartiles — calculated within a subject category over several years. A journal must first be indexed in Scopus or WoS, then accumulate citations, before any quartile exists. A complete standards-grade policy framework is the entry requirement for indexing and the foundation that helps earn citations; it cannot by itself produce a Q1/Q2 rank.

Indexing & database readiness

DatabaseCore requirementStatus
DOAJ OA statement, CC licence, author-retained copyright, peer-review & ethics policies, editorial board, APC transparency, ISSN Policy in place
Crossref DOI registration + rich XML metadata deposit Operational
Google Scholar Highwire citation meta tags, HTML+PDF full text, stable URLs Policy in place
OpenAlex Harvests Crossref / open metadata Met via Crossref
Scopus (CSAB) Peer-review policy, COPE ethics, editorial board with affiliations, ISSN, on-time publication, DOIs, content quality & citedness Policy in place
Web of Science (Clarivate) Editorial rigour, Peer Review, ethics, board diversity, timeliness; ESCI first, then SCIE/SSCI/AHCI on impact Policy in place
PubMed Central / MEDLINE Scientific + editorial quality; JATS XML full text; ethics, consent, trial registration Policy in place
Publons / WoS Reviewer Recognition Reviewer recognition integration & verified review records Policy in place
ORCID Authenticated iDs for authors (and reviewers) Policy in place

Scopus & Web of Science selection criteria — mapped

Both databases evaluate journals against broadly similar quality signals. Typical criteria and where each is addressed:

Selection criterionWhere addressedStatus
Convincing editorial concept / clear Aims & Scope Aims & Scope page Policy in place
Peer Review policy, clearly described Peer Review Policy Policy in place
Publication ethics & malpractice statement (COPE) Publication Ethics + ethics set Policy in place
Editorial board — identifiable, with affiliations & diversity Editorial Board page Policy in place
Regular, on-time publication + stated frequency Publication Frequency page Policy in place
ISSN, English titles & abstracts, references in Roman script Author Guidelines + metadata Policy in place
DOIs & quality metadata Metadata Policy Operational
Content relevance, originality & academic contribution Editorial + Peer Review standards Policy in place
Citedness of articles / journal impact Citation performance over time Performance-based
International diversity of authors, reviewers & board Governance + outreach Performance-based

Verify current criteria

Selection guidance is updated periodically. Confirm against the official sources before applying: Scopus content policy, Web of Science editorial selection process, PMC/MEDLINE, ICMJE and DOAJ.

Full policy suite

The complete set a top-tier, internationally indexed journal is expected to publish:

Author policies

Author GuidelinesAuthorship & Contributorship (ICMJE + CRediT)ORCID requirementData Availability / SharingAI use & disclosurePublication ethicsInformed consent / research ethicsCopyright & licence (CC)APC & waivers

Reviewer policies

Peer Review PolicyReviewer selection criteria & guidelinesReviewer conflict of interestReviewer confidentiality & AI-in-reviewPeer Review recognition

Editorial policies

Editorial PolicyEditorial independenceEditorial Board & GovernanceEditor conflict of interest & recusalAppeals & complaints

Journal / publisher policies

Aims & ScopeAbout / Ownership & ManagementPublication frequency & scheduleOpen accessCopyright · Licensing · Self-archivingCorrections · Retraction · WithdrawalDigital preservation & archivingMetadata (Crossref · JATS · OAI-PMH · Scholar)

Legal policies

Privacy (GDPR / DPDP)Terms & ConditionsDisclaimer

Path to indexing

Publish consistently on schedule, then apply to DOAJ first, followed by Scopus and Web of Science (ESCI). Quartile standing follows once citations accrue.

Frameworks & bodies referenced

COPEICMJEDOAJOASPAWAMEScopus / CSABWeb of SciencePubMed / PMC / MEDLINEPublonsDeclaration of HelsinkiWHO ICTRPARRIVE 2.0CONSORTPRISMASTROBEFAIRTOPCrossref / CrossmarkDataCiteNISO JATSORCIDROR

Editorial Policies · Open Access & Copyright · Publishing & Legal Policies

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙